| First Team | ||
|---|---|---|
| Player | School | Year |
| Forwards | ||
| Tyler Cuba | JR | Notre Dame |
| Adam Garrett | JR | Sikeston |
| Tanner Fritz | SO | Sikeston |
| Midfielders | ||
| Brandon DeWitt | JR | Sikeston |
| John Lamping | SR | St. Pius |
| Scott Wittenborn | JR | Notre Dame |
| Shane Kistner | JR | Notre Dame |
| Defenders | ||
| Mike Speck | SR | St. Pius |
| Nick Kapfer | SR | Notre Dame |
| Adam Prasanphanich | SO | Notre Dame |
| Goalie | ||
| Jake Curtis | SR | Sikeston |
