| Player | Position | School | Year |
| First Team | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Jesse Baker | MF | Liberty | SR |
| Tim Collico | F | Chaminade | SR |
| Kai Harris | F | Oakville | SR |
| Dan Hartwig | MF | SLUH | SR |
| Kyle Hency | D | Chaminade | JR |
| Kyle Hobson | MF | Oakville | SR |
| Matt Hoff | MF | Chaminade | JR |
| William John | MF | Rockhurst | JR |
| Steve Kozeny | GK | Chaminade | SR |
| Cooper McKee | F | Chaminade | SR |
| Alex Matteson | MF | Chaminade | JR |
| Ian Mulligan | D | SLUH | SR |
| Charlie Peters | F | Rockhurst | SR |
| Chad Ramey | D | Oak Park | SR |
| Matt Riegert | D | Oakville | SR |
| Kevin Robsen | MF | Chaminade | JR |
| Drew Southards | D | Francis Howell North | SR |
| John Mark Thomson | MF | Cape Girardeau Central | SR |
| Isaac Unruh | GK | St. Joe Central | SR |
| David Walters | F | Ritenour | SR |
| Michael White | GK | Glendale | SR |
| Dan Wynn | MF | Chaminade | SR |
| Mike Zagel | GD | CBC | SR |
| Second Team | |||
| Trevor Blattner | GK | Cape Girardeau Central | SR |
| Matt Boyer | GK | Oakville | SR |
| Dave Brown | F | Northwest House Springs | SR |
| Landon Burke | D | Truman | SR |
| Mike Comiskey | D | Rockhurst | JR |
| John Dressler | MF | Glendale | SR |
| Brian Forest | GK | DeSmet | SR |
| Nick Fredrickson | MF | DeSmet | SR |
| Joe Germanese | F | SLUH | SO |
| Dustin Green | F | North Kansas City | SR |
| Brandon Hargis | GK | Liberty | JR |
| Brian Higgins | MF | CBC | SR |
| Pat Kelly | GK | CBC | SR |
| Brett Loving | MF | St. Joe Central | JR |
| Andy Moses | MF | Chaminade | SR |
| Nick Nava | D | Liberty | SR |
| Allan Nekuda | F | Liberty | SR |
| Taylor Reid | MF | Rock Bridge | SR |
| Mark Spiegel | F | Lee's Summit North | JR |
| Dan Stull | MF | Parkway South | SR |
| Aaron Thompson | D | Chaminade | JR |
| Jason Titus | MF | Lee's Summit | JR |
| Tim Velton | D | Webster Groves | SR |
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Robby Borchardt | D | Rockhurst | SO |
| Matt Bruno | MF | Rolla | SR |
| Dan Edgar | F | Ft. Zumwalt West | SR |
| Dan Gajewski | D | Ft. Zumwalt South | JR |
| Matt Gordon | MF | Jackson | SR |
| Brad Hamm | F | Kickapoo | JR |
| Patrick Kohm | F | Jackson | SR |
| Sal Loporto | MF | Blue Springs South | SR |
| Blake Michel | MF | Marquette | SR |
| Sam Phelps | D | Jefferson City | JR |
| Job Richardson | F | Francis Howell Central | SR |
| Kyle Riesselman | GK | Hickman | SR |
